Let’s get one thing straight right off the bat: talk therapy can be incredible. For some people, it’s a lifesaver. But I’ve heard from countless women who say they’ve spent years in therapy—only to end up feeling worse, labeled “difficult,” or convinced they’re broken beyond repair. If that hits home, this post is for you.
Today, we’re digging into three reasons why traditional, talk-based therapy might leave you feeling stuck in burnout or anxiety—and more importantly, what you can do about it. Let’s dive in.
1. Trauma Lives in the Body, Not Just the Mind
Here’s the foundational idea: trauma is stored in your body and nervous system, not just your thoughts or beliefs. Research shows that a staggering 80% of the signals that regulate how we feel actually start in the body and travel up to the brain. But typical talk therapy often zeroes in on analyzing thoughts, feelings, and behaviors—talking about the trauma, dissecting it, labeling it.
The Catch?
Your trauma isn’t hanging out in the “thinking” part of your brain. It’s essentially an uncompleted stress response that got stuck in your body. When you just talk about it, your nervous system can’t tell the difference between talking about the event and reliving it. Without tools that actively signal safety to your body, you might re-experience the same overwhelm all over again.
Real-Life Example
Clients tell me, “My therapist wants me to describe my trauma in detail, and after every session, I feel raw and more anxious.” That’s your survival response firing up, because your body thinks you’re back in the danger zone—but there’s no body-based toolkit to ground you.
Takeaway
If talk therapy alone has left you feeling more dysregulated, it’s not a sign you’re hopeless or “too damaged.” It’s a sign you need an approach that helps your body release trauma, not just talk about it.
2. Talking About Your Past Can Be Dysregulating by Nature
Remember this: when you recall a distressing event, your brain’s alarm system (the amygdala) blares like a siren. It doesn’t matter if you’re in a calm office or actually in the thick of a dangerous situation—your body can’t instantly tell the difference. That sympathetic nervous system response (fight or flight) kicks in, flooding you with stress hormones. So if you’re simply retelling your painful story without grounding or somatic practices, you can end up re-traumatizing yourself.
Why Talk Therapy Might Miss the Mark
Many forms of talk therapy, like CBT, aim to change unhelpful thoughts or behaviors. That’s great, unless your body is already stuck in high alert mode. In that case, you’re not processing anything; you’re just reactivating old stress and piling on more.
The Missing Piece
You need to feel physically and emotionally safe while you process painful memories. That means having a plan to track your body’s responses—like a rise in heart rate or a shallower breath—and using tools to help you calm down in the moment. Without these, you’re essentially swimming in a pool of stress chemicals every time you talk about what happened.
3. You Can’t Outthink Nervous System Dysregulation
You might understand why you feel anxious or depressed. You might have dug up the root causes and know all the triggers. But if your survival brain is on high alert, pure logic won’t shut it off.
Different Brain Regions, Different Languages
- Your prefrontal cortex (thinking brain) can analyze, reason, and intellectualize.
- Your limbic system and brainstem (emotional and survival brains) respond to threats before you can say “cognitive distortion.”
So, yes, you might tell yourself, “I’m safe now,” but your body might still scream, “Danger!” if it hasn’t completed that stress cycle and truly learned to relax again.
Real Talk
That’s why you can have all the insight in the world yet still face panic attacks, insomnia, or debilitating anxiety. Knowledge is a great start, but it can’t override your body’s automatic reflexes.
What Works Instead?
Body-based tools—somatic work, breathwork, grounding exercises, and more—allow your system to actually feel safety. They teach your survival brain, “We can stand down now,” on a physical level.
Why This Matters (and What to Do Next)
None of this is meant to discredit talk therapy. If it’s helping you, keep going! But if you’ve been talking until you’re blue in the face and still feeling trapped in anxiety or burnout, please know you’re not alone—and you’re not failing.
Trauma, anxiety, and burnout often need more than talk. They need tangible, body-based tools that help you experience safety, not just understand it. That’s when true healing can start.
Your Next Step
Check out my Nervous System Reset Guide (link in the show notes). It’s a deep dive into how to start healing from the inside out, using somatic and nervous system approaches that might be the missing link you’ve been searching for.
Remember:
- You can’t simply think your way out of a stress response.
- You have to feel your way through it—supported by practices that help your body rewrite its stress patterns.
That’s where the real magic happens.
If you’ve tried talk therapy and left feeling more anxious, more hopeless, or more confused—don’t blame yourself. Chances are, you just need a different toolkit, one designed to communicate with your nervous system in its own language.
- Trauma lives in the body. Talking alone can’t fully reach it.
- Talking about your past can be triggering if you aren’t grounded in safety strategies.
- You can’t outsmart your survival responses; body-based work is key.
Talk therapy can be amazing. But if it’s not your silver bullet, you’re not broken—you have other options. Consider adding a somatic, nervous system-based approach to your healing journey. Learn to feel safe in your body, not just think about safety. Your healing deserves that and so much more.
MY BURNOUT RECOVERY STORY + $10 OFF HAPPY JUICE
Have a question you’d love Michelle to answer on the podcast? “Ask Michelle a Question.” Click this link, record your message, hit send, and I’ll answer it in a future episode!
+ show Comments
- Hide Comments
add a comment