Ever catch yourself thinking, “But wait—I have a good job, a loving family, I’m not living in an actual warzone…so why does my body still freak out like it’s Defcon 1?” If that sounds familiar, this post is for you. We’re diving into why we get stuck in fight-or-flight mode even though we’re objectively safe—and how to finally start teaching your nervous system that it can stand down.

---

The Constant Scanning: Why Our Bodies Are Always on High Alert

Here’s a quick crash course in Nervous System (NS) 101:

• Your NS’s top priority is to keep you alive.
• It’s constantly scanning your environment—both around you and inside you—for any sign of danger.
• It also checks in with your “internal memory bank” (i.e., past experiences) to see if anything feels remotely like a previous threat.

Where It Gets Tricky

If you had a super-critical caregiver or authority figure in your past, you might now interpret even mild criticism at work as a direct threat. For example, your boss says, “Can we talk?” and your body’s already screaming, “Abort mission!” even if the boss just wants to give you a (much-dreamed-of) bonus.

In our modern world, we’re not outrunning actual tigers, but our system can get triggered by things like tense emails, side-eye from a coworker, or your partner texting “We need to talk.” Essentially, if it resembles any old threat, your NS flips that danger switch—and fight-or-flight mode is activated.

---

Why Logic Alone Doesn’t Solve It

Cognitive vs. Felt Sense

Your logical brain might say, “We’re safe, calm down,” but your body is busy recalling that time you were shamed in school for asking a ‘dumb question.’ When your body believes it’s under attack, it does not care about intellectual reassurances.

• Thinking Mind: “Everything’s fine, relax.”
• Body’s Survival Mind: “No, we remember how this went down last time, and it was bad news!”

You can’t just “tell” your NS to calm down; it only gets the message when you show it—via consistent, body-based experiences of safety.

---

Reason #1: A Database of Past Experiences

Your NS is kind of like that phone you’ve been ignoring system updates on. It’s loaded with all your past moments of perceived danger, and it hasn’t gotten the memo that life’s different now.

1. Old Database: Every time you felt threatened—physically or emotionally—got stored as “the world isn’t safe.” So your body sees even a hint of potential conflict (like a coworker’s disapproving look) and freaks out.
2. Why We Freeze or Flee: Your body thinks it’s doing you a favor. It’s ready to spring into action based on the data it has—no matter how old that data is.

Key Takeaway: You’re not flawed or overreacting; your NS is just really efficient at its job. It just needs some serious software updates.

---

Reason #2: The NS Doesn’t Speak Logic

This is why “positive thinking” alone doesn’t cut it. When something feels like a threat, the survival parts of your brain light up and overshadow your logical mind.

• Words vs. Sensations: You might think, “I’m okay; I’m safe,” but your racing heart and tightening chest aren’t following that script.
• Felt Sense of Safety: Real healing happens when you repeatedly show your body, through new experiences, that situations you once perceived as threats can turn out just fine.

Translation: Your nervous system only believes what it experiences—not what you merely tell it.

---

Reason #3: Your System Needs to See New Outcomes

We can’t expect our NS to update automatically—it needs evidence. If you once believed that “speaking up = punishment,” the only way to shift that belief is by safely speaking up in small ways and noticing you didn’t end up ridiculed or rejected.

1. Relationships as an Example
   Think of a new friendship or partnership. You probably didn’t trust them right away, but over time, with repeated positive interactions, your guard slowly dropped. Your body “learned” they were safe.
2. Building Capacity
   Every time you face a small threat—like emailing someone you’re nervous about, or having a direct conversation—and it goes okay, your system logs that as “Huh, we survived.” Over time, those “we survived” moments accumulate, giving your NS a brand-new script.

---

How to Teach Your NS That It’s Safe

1. Identify a Small Edge

Pick something that feels slightly uncomfortable but not terrifying. Maybe it’s speaking up in a meeting once this week, or sending that vulnerable text you’ve been putting off.

2. Prep Your Body

Before you do the thing, check in. Are your shoulders up by your ears? Is your breathing shallow? Use a grounding technique—like a few slow, deep breaths or placing a hand on your heart—to remind your system it’s safe.

3. Experience It

Go ahead and do the scary-but-manageable thing. Stay present in your body, even if you feel that wave of anxiety. Let yourself see the outcome in real time.

4. Process the Aftermath

Ask yourself: Did the apocalypse happen? Probably not. Let that relief sink in. Your system needs this info: “I did it, and I’m okay.”

5. Rinse & Repeat

Consistency is the secret sauce. With every small success, your NS slowly updates its threat database.

---

Why Slowness Is Your Secret Weapon

I know hustle culture trained us to want results yesterday. But nervous system healing isn’t a race. Going too fast can backfire by reactivating old trauma rather than rewiring it.

• Building Capacity Gradually: Your capacity is the “amount of stress or discomfort you can tolerate before freaking out.” Each gentle step stretches that capacity.
• Acceptance: If something feels too big, scale back. You’re not weak, you’re wise. Slow progress is still progress—and often creates the most resilient change.

---

Your Next Step: Grab the Nervous System Reset Guide

Ready for more hands-on strategies to calm your fight-or-flight? My Nervous System Reset Guide is a free resource packed with daily micro-practices that help you “show” your body it’s safe, moment by moment. Check out the link in the show notes to start integrating these tools into your routine.

So, why do you still feel stuck in fight-or-flight even though life is “fine” on paper?

1. You’re working off an outdated database of threats from the past.
2. Logic isn’t the NS’s native language—it responds to body-based cues of safety.
3. You need new experiences that prove (in real time) you’re not in danger anymore.

Final Truth: Your system’s not broken. It’s just a little behind the times. With patience, repeated safe experiences, and gentle self-compassion, you can help it finally update those ancient files. That’s how real, lasting transformation takes root.

You’ve got this! Slow and steady, one small step at a time. Because yes, you deserve to feel safe in your own body—and that’s absolutely possible with the right approach. Let’s do this.

MY BURNOUT RECOVERY STORY + $10 OFF HAPPY JUICE

Have a question you’d love Michelle to answer on the podcast? “Ask Michelle a Question.” Click this link, record your message, hit send, and I’ll answer it in a future episode!